WE ARE HOMETOWN NEWS.

Progress made on renovating Springfield’s Old First Church

by | Nov 18, 2026 | Hampden County, Local News, Springfield

Crews work on the facade of Old First Church.
Reminder Publishing photo by Sarah Heinonen

SPRINGFIELD — Over the past few months, anyone walking by Springfield’s Old First Church has seen the historic building receiving a facelift.

In July, the city announced it would begin $2.62 million worth of renovations to the building’s exterior, including sheeting, siding, painting and replacing boards, as well as some masonry work. Since then, Kronenburger & Sons Restoration has been working on the 200-year-old building.

While the project is not yet finished, several key repairs have been made. Among them, the primary moisture barrier on wood siding was restored, the deterioration of the steeple was addressed, and the columns were repaired and reconstructed. The church’s interior rafters were also repaired. Additionally, the church’s clock has been restored and is in working order. At the attached parish house, the ceilings, floors and decking were repaired and the roof was replaced.

Municipal Buildings Director Jon Carignan said the project has gone well, despite the challenges of working with limited access in a busy area of downtown. He said the need to preserve the historic nature of the building meant the crews had to “proceed with the utmost caution. There was significant thought and planning put into place before work began to plan for the potential unexpected, and I believe that planning has served us well to date.”

The church was built in 1819, as the town of Springfield’s fourth meeting house. It is the oldest building in downtown Springfield, and many historical figures walked its floorboards, including Secretary of State Daniel Webster, abolitionist John Brown and Jenny Lind, a Swedish opera singer. Former President John Quincy Adams laid in state inside the church. It was also a stop on the Underground Railroad.

This phase of the project, which addressed the most needed repairs to the building’s exterior, will be finished in December. Future phases will begin to tackle the remaining exterior issues and the building’s interior needs. Carignan said the goal is to make the church accessible and open it to redevelopment.

While the structure’s original assessment of the church in 2020 estimated $5 million in repairs, Carignan said the escalation of construction costs will be a factor in how much the church’s total restoration will cost. So far, the work has been undertaken with American Rescue Plan Act funding and money from Springfield’s Community Preservation program.

In a press release on the progress, Mayor Domenic Sarno thanked Neal for securing the federal funds. He also thanked Community Preservation Committee Chair Bob McCarroll.

“Old First Church was a very popular venue and we are thrilled to be able to continue working to restore it to its proper glory,” stated Sarno. “Court Square has undergone major renovations, and the next step is stabilizing this iconic Springfield structure. I commend and thank my city team with Parks Director Tom Ashe, our Municipal Buildings Director Jon Carignan, Chief Development Officer Tim Sheehan, and Deputy Tina Quagliato Sullivan for all their efforts to preserve, maintain and redevelop Old First Church.”

Carignan said, “Historic structures, such as Old First Church, require significant funding to ensure they are preserved,” said Carignan. “We are fortunate to have such strong advocates in Mayor Sarno and Congressman Neal, who continue to advocate for these buildings. We have a number of irons in the fire, so to speak, and look forward to the continuation of this work.”

sheinonen@thereminder.com | + posts